War Arrow

John McIntire

Rufus (voice)

Henry Brandon

Chief Cicatriz (Scar)

Suzan Ball

Black Shawl

Jeff Chandler

Jonathan Westgate

Charles Drake

Ken Bronson

Noah Beery Jr.

Sam

Ezelle Poule

Older mistaken identity (uncredited)

Dennis Weaver

Matt Jessup

Dee Carroll

Telephone Operator (uncredited)

Jim Bannon

Col. Morse

Jay Silverheels

Cajou

Bradford Jackson

Al Turner

Maureen O'Hara

Doris Walker

Stephen Wyman

Captain Neil (as Steve Wyman)